A Comparative Study of Materials in the Design of Concrete and Asphalt Road Pavements in Terms of Cost and Time (Case Study of the Sumberwudi-Maduran Road Section, Lamongan Regency, East Java Province)

Johan Sanjoko; Andi Patriadi; Retno Hastijanti

doi:10.55927/fjst.v5i1.370

Authors

Johan Sanjoko Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Surabaya
Andi Patriadi Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Surabaya
Retno Hastijanti Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Surabaya

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55927/fjst.v5i1.370

Keywords:

Concrete Pavement, Asphalt Pavement, Rigid Pavement

Abstract

This research is highly urgent in bridging the knowledge gap between standard theory, field practice, and the dynamics of current industrial area development. The construction and periodic maintenance budget for asphalt road pavement with a duration of 20 years requires a cost of Rp. 17,638,200,000.00, then the construction and periodic maintenance budget for asphalt road pavement with a duration of 40 years requires a cost of Rp. 52,225,100,000.00. The construction and periodic maintenance budget for 20-year UR concrete road pavement requires a cost of Rp. 9,063,000,000.00, then the construction and periodic maintenance budget for 40-year UR concrete road pavement requires a cost of Rp. 15,031,400,000.00.

References

Abd. Kadir Salim, Muhammad Akhyar Darmawan, & Harun Wibowo. (2020). Comparative Analysis of Rigi and Flexible Pavement Costs on the Makassar City Middle Ring Road Project.

Adhita Maharani. (2018). Comparison of Rigid and Flexible Pavements (Case Study of the Prigi–Popoh Beach Highway Section, Tulungagung Regency).

Aditiya, R. E., & Siswoyo, S. (2020). Rigid Pavement Design and Budget Plan on the Babat–Jombang Boundary Road, Lamongan Regency.

American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials. (1993). AASHTO Guide for Design of Pavement Structures. Washington, D.C.

Asidin. (2021). Flexible Pavement Thickness Planning Using the Road Pavement Design Manual Method in Lakambau Village, Batauga District, South Buton Regency.

Assa, T. F., Palenewen, S. C. N., & Waani, J. E. (2022). Comparison of Flexible Pavement and Rigid Pavement Thickness Analysis Against Cost Budget Plans.

Austroad. (1987). Pavement Design: A Guide to the Structural Design of Road Pavements. Austroad Incorporated, Australia.

Azizi Muhammad Nasution. (2019). Comparison of Pavement Thickness to Road Class.

Central Statistics Agency. (2023). Number of Motorized Vehicles by Province and Vehicle Type.

Central Statistics Agency of Lamongan Regency. (2023). Lamongan Regency in Figures 2023.

Central Statistics Agency of East Java Province. (n.d.). Official Website of the Statistics Indonesia (BPS) of East Java Province.

Directorate General of Highways. (2024). Road Pavement Design Manual (MBM 2024). Ministry of Public Works and Public Housing.

Directorate General of Highways. (n.d.). Road and Bridge Journal.

Department of Settlement and Regional Infrastructure. (2002). Flexible Pavement Thickness Design for T-01-2002-B. Jakarta.

Department of Settlement and Regional Infrastructure. (2003). Cement Concrete Road Pavement Design for T-14-2003. Jakarta.

Diantoro, W. (2023), Comparison of the Use of Cantilever and Gravity Retaining Walls with Variations in Slope Height of Mount Lio Salem, Brebes Regency.

Lamongan Regency Public Works and Public Housing Agency. (2021–2026). Review of the 2021–2026 Public Works and Public Housing Agency Strategic Plan.

Grobogan Regency Public Works and Public Housing Agency. (n.d.). Flexible Pavement Construction.

Espacial Artwork. (n.d.). SatuPeta.

Fajarianto, D. Y., Poerwanto, J. A., & Ratnaningsih, D. (2023). Comparison of Rigid Pavement Using the 2017 Bina Marga Method and Austroad on the Purworejo-Senduro Highway in Lumajang Regency

Firmansyah, R., DAS, A. M., & Dony, W. (2022). Rigid Pavement Design for Structural Capacity Reconstruction on Bensol Road, Jambi City

Hardiyatmo, H. C. (2015). Road Pavement Design and Soil Investigation. Gadjah Mada University Press.

Ibrahim M. Narendra A. (2023), Comparison of Rigid and Flexible Pavements Based on Cost and Design Life (Case Study of Lot 3 of Kretek 2 Bridge, Bantul)

Kamil, F., Setiawan, A., & Purnomo, J. (2023). Rigid Pavement Design for Damaged Wolter Monginsidi Road

Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries. (2023). 2023 Annual Report. Jakarta.

Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries. (n.d.). Profile of Brondong Archipelago Fishing Port.

Ministry of Public Works. (2013). Road Pavement Design Manual Number 02/M/BM/2013.

Ministry of Public Works. (2017). Road Pavement Design Manual Number 02/M/BM/2017.

Ministry of Public Works and Public Housing. (n.d.). Regency Road Surface Conditions.

Kurniawan, H., & Djunaidi, Mr. (2020). Comparative Study of Flexible Pavement and Rigid Pavement Construction in Terms of Cost. Case Study: Improving the Quality of the Sungai Pinang-Pantai Mempanak Road, Lingga Regency

Lelepadang, S., Nuhun, R., Nasrul, N., & Ahmad, S. N. (2020). Comparative Analysis of Rigid Pavement and Flexible Pavement Construction Costs (Case Study: Prof. M. Yamin Road, Puuwatu Village, Kendari City)

Mahardika, V., Mudiyono, R., & Soedarsono, S. (2021). Comparison of Construction and Costs for Flexible, Rigid, and Block Pavement Structures on the North Flores Coastal Road

Muhammad Iqbal Saefulloh. (2022). Flexible Pavement Thickness Analysis of Tawang–Ngalang Road Segment IV and Klangon–Tempel Road Using the 2017 MDPJ Method.

Lamongan Regency Government. (2024). Lamongan Map System (SKALA). h

Lamongan Regency Government. (n.d.). Official Portal of Lamongan Regency.

Lamongan Regency Public Works and Public Housing Agency (PPID). (2023). Government Agency Performance Report (LKjIP) 2023 – Public Works and Highways Agency.

Prasetya, E. J., Marleno, R., & Tjendani, H. T. (2023). Investment Cost Analysis of Flexible and Rigid Pavements (Case Study of the Access Road Section of the PPI-TPI Romokalisari Flats in Surabaya)

Prasojo, G., and Narendra, A. (2023). Comparative Analysis of Rigid and Flexible Pavement Thickness Using the 2017 MDPJ Method

Putri Zayu, W., Vitri, G., Herman, H., & Fadel, R. (2022). Comparison of Flexible and Rigid Pavement Construction on the Gulang-Gulang Road, Koto Hamlet, Sawah Lunto City, Station 0+000 – 0+500 Km

Radar Bangsa. (n.d.). Regent Yuhronur Ensures Increasingly Stable Lamongan Roads.

Ridwan, A., & Romadhon, F. (2019). Rigid Pavement Planning Analysis for the Plosoklaten-Gedangsewu Road, Kediri Regency Scribd. (n.d.). Lamongan Map.

Cabinet Secretariat of the Republic of Indonesia. (2021). Dialogue with Fishermen Representatives of Lamongan Regency at the Brondong PPN.

Simanjuntak, W. M. S. (2023). Economic Comparison of Flexible and Rigid Pavement Thickness Design for the Kampung Pon-Bakaran Batu (Kelapa Tinggi) Road Construction Project

Sutapa, I. K., Wirahaji, I. B., & Ariadi, I. M. G. (2022). Comparative Analysis of Rigid and Flexible Pavements in the Celukan Bawang-Pelabuhan Road Improvement Project

Tiara, M., Rochmanto, D., & Saputro, Y. A. (2022). Rigid Pavement Thickness Design for the Jepara Bangsri Highway Section at KM 11 to KM 12 Using the 2017 Bina Marga Guidelines

Woro Sukarno, E. (2022). Case Study: Comparative Cost Efficiency between Rigid Pavement and Flexible Pavement Road Work in Ngawi Regency

Unesa. (n.d.). Journal of Civil Engineering.

Diponegoro University. (n.d.). CHAPTER II (Academic Document).

Universitas Pahlawan. (n.d.). Journal of Civil Engineering.

Woro Sukarno, E. (2022). Comparison of Cost Efficiency between Rigid and Flexible Pavements in Ngawi Regency.